Peter Fletcher

  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact

Aesthetics as Ethics

June 3, 2008 by Peter Fletcher

Correction: The following post refers to Lois McNaly and should properly read Lois McNay. My apology to the author.

–––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––

In the book, Foucault, Lois McNaly (1994, p. 149) critiques Michel Foucault’s notion of aestheticism or the aesthetics of the self/existence as being overly reliant on the heroization of the self.

Foucault utilised Baudelaire the Dandy as a way to exemplify the way an individual might bring themselves forth into the world; a way of producing oneself as a work of art. This work of art is said to have a non-productive quality and by that I believe Foucault was suggesting the production of art for arts sake, not the production of art in some attempt at communicative reason. It sounds as though he was attempting to be elitist by having people create themselves as pieces of high art that served ‘no’ purpose. But in reality he was attempting to bring art to the grasp of all individuals. We can each create our own lives as a work of art without first finding some form of hidden existential being lurking deep below the surface. Foucault, I believe, was simply attempting, through Baudelaire the Dandy, to demonstrate that self mastery was immanent and immediately available for all human beings. No need to wait for the shrink, just start producing art.

But McNaly’s critique is leveled against what she sees as the underlying gendered tones of the invocation of Foucault’s heroic male artist. McNaly believes that the subtext of Foucault’s Dandy is unaddressed and therefore the aesthetics have become fetishized; given more meaning and power then they deserve.

I don’t share McNaly’s criticism. Foucault might have employed any other of a myriad illustrations to explain and demonstrate his notion. Instead he chose a Dandy artist who become heroized by academics; and its regrettable this occurred. For me, Foucault was simply attempting to provide a sense of the now available to each of us. In the same way as an artist stills the mind in the creative moment, Foucault was attempting to explain something difficult, if not impossible, to understand at the level of the intellect.

McNaly, L. (1994). Foucault. Oxford: Polity Press.

Take a moment to share:

  • Tweet
  • Email

Related posts:

  1. Aesthetics as Ethics Part 2 Came across a couple of neat definitions today in McNaly...
  2. New Spaces | Foucault Just read a book chapter written by Foucault (1998) on...
  3. Race, time and the revision of culture |Bhahba Don’t try and make too much of this post. I’m...
  4. Reflections on Subjectivity In my last meeting with my PhD supervisors I was...
  5. Personal emancipation I’m having trouble with the term personal emancipation and the...

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: Lois McNaly, Michel Foucault

About Peter

Speaker, trainer and coach. I write about living, loving and working better. Love a challenge. More...

Subscribe

Get the latest posts delivered to your inbox.

Recent Posts

  • Perth property market report
  • Mandating madness: The case against compulsory e-conveyancing
  • PEXA: Stop treating conveyancers like idiots
  • Page 1 of 365
  • Looking back, looking forward

Top Posts & Pages

  • Foucault on Confession
  • Why saying "You've got potential" can be the worst thing to say
  • Foucault on power relations
  • Page 1 of 365
  • Databases as discourse | Mark Poster
  • Blog
  • Civil society: Beyond the public sphere | Jodi Dean
  • Why I'm interested in self-writing and the hupomnemata
  • Nine things successful people do differently
  • Zen and the art of the cold shower

Location

You can find me at Residential Settlements in Burswood.

5/170 Burswood Road
Burswood WA 6100

Let’s catch up

If you're ready to take your business to the next level, get in touch with me now.

Send me an email using the contact form or call me direct on 0419 538 838.

Connect

Connect with me on one of these social networks.
  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • Tumblr
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2021 · Agency Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.