Peter Fletcher

  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact

A little more on Dean and Habermas

March 27, 2008 by Peter Fletcher

I’m sitting here racking my brain attempting to figure out how I can make a comment on Jodi Dean’s scholarly critique of Jurgen Habermas’s theory/notion/concept of the public sphere interesting, readable, and enjoyable. I sense the task is simply not possible. So rather I’ll attempt to boil Dean’s work down to something that’s brief.

As I see the public sphere after reading Dean is that it’s a way of conceiving how life works in democracy. Habermas modeled his concept of the public sphere on the ‘table societies’ of France, England, and Germany. These were groups of literary elites – writers and publishers of letters – who sat around drinking coffee and talking about the concerns of the day. As I read Dean, their concerns were twofold. First, being they were blokes, what was going on at home, and secondly, being they were supposedly intelligent debaters, what was going on with the state and the economy. Because they were also writers they concerned themselves with holding at bay the power of the state – a bit like a bunch of bike riders sitting around debating whether the state can tell them to wear helmets. They were also worried about the encroachment of the economy on their lives, kind of like the way people get passionate about the merits of extended trading hours or developing the foreshore.

Dean saw this model of society as problematic. For a starter, you’ll notice that there were no women mentioned in the examples given above. That’s the way the table societies started. Blokes talking about blokey things. As the years progressed these gender-biased discourses became institutionalised in a way that not only was it difficult for women to be involved in the debate without becoming ‘blokey’, it became almost impossible to even question what subjects were worth debating and how they should be debated in the first place. For Dean, Habermas’s reliance on rational debate and critical dialogue was simply too stifling, too restrictive, and too dull. It had to be thrown out.

So Dean, along with other scholars, proposed the notion of civil society. Rather than seeing power coming from outside, as in the way the public sphere tries to keep the power at bay, she sees power, with all its messiness, coming from inside civil society. She sees civil society (and Dean would probably kill me for this) as a great big melting pot of difference, and diversity, and styles of self-expression, a site of “relationships of recognition” (p. 236).

If I’ve butchered Dean’s critique in these few words, or made light of it, I don’t mean to; her work provides promise and hope for the future of democracy and society. And if I have provided a misguided understanding of these important concepts, please feel free to make a comment.

After all, this very forum is civil society.

Footnote: this post was originally published on Curtin’s webct.

Related posts:

  1. Civil society: Beyond the public sphere | Jodi Dean This is a review of a book chapter from Jodi...
  2. Foucault on power relations Please note: this post is under construction whilst I read...
  3. Self-writing, frank and fearless speech I’ve been reading The Political Mapping of Cyberspace by Jeremy...
  4. Coral Bay Beach Resort project now complete I have just completed a site for Coral Bay Beach...
  5. Dean Bradley Launches New Site I’m proud to announce that Dean Bradley has just launched...

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: civil society, habermas, jodi dean, the public sphere

About Peter

Speaker, trainer and coach. I write about living, loving and working better. Love a challenge. More...

Subscribe

Get the latest posts delivered to your inbox.

Recent Posts

  • The Perth Property Market: Free Drinks For Everyone
  • Perth Property Market Performance – W/E 22 August 2021
  • Perth property market report
  • Mandating madness: The case against compulsory e-conveyancing
  • PEXA: Stop treating conveyancers like idiots

Location

You can find me at Residential Settlements in Burswood.

5/170 Burswood Road
Burswood WA 6100

Let’s catch up

If you're ready to take your business to the next level, get in touch with me now.

Send me an email using the contact form or call me direct on 0419 538 838.

Connect

Connect with me on one of these social networks.
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Tumblr
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2022 · Agency Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in